![]() ![]() ![]() Why? What qualities and circumstances make a gift good or make the gift-giving act good? In the book, several gifts for Eli are compared and contrasted. This theme naturally lends itself to a parallel discussion about value and the objective or subjective features to which we attribute various types of value. The philosophical big ideas in Punchinello and the Most Marvelous Gift center on the exploration of what constitutes a good gift and what makes gift-giving and receiving special. ![]() This “most marvelous gift” touches Eli’s heart and is acclaimed as the best part of Maker Day. By the end of the story, Punchinello and the rest of the Wemmicks realize that Maker Day is not about impressing one another or Eli with gifts, but rather about expressing gratitude to Eli. Several Wemmicks try to outdo each other to make the best gift for Eli. Questions for Philosophical Discussion » Summary What does it mean to give a gift? What makes some gifts better than others?Īll of Wemmicksville is decorated and bustling with preparations for the Maker Day festival in honor of Eli, the woodcarver who makes all the wooden toys. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |